Snowball by Zoe Davis
“I just don’t know what it is with this one. It was one I liked and then didn’t like and then liked again, so submitted it – got rejected- and then I convinced myself it was awful. It’s seasonal and a bit moody, and I think the lines are too long. Not sure what the message is here, except don’t throw things at people with rocks in them. It’s not nice. Oh, and capitalising random words clearly has a deeper meaning. *rolls eyes at self*”
February Snows by Zoe Davis
“Okay, so I thought I was being so edgy coming up with ‘archipelago of sin’. I mean… what does that really mean? This was literally one of the first poems I wrote when I decided to start doing things a bit more seriously, and clearly wanted that to be expressed by using long words and odd metaphors about the body being some kind of dread land mass. Oh, and I make the words look a bit like a mountain at the end. -_- This just embarrasses me and yet it’s still kinda special because I know how much I tried to write something ‘good’.”
some mistake by Ivona Bozik
“I doubted this piece a lot, because I usually don't write in English and even more rarely write poetry. These words just burst out one time when I was reminiscing while cooking lunch, so they seemed too direct, personal and random to become an actual poem. As often, the thoughts insisted till I wrote them down. And then, I forgot about them for some time, but I don't know... for me, there is still something touching about them. The way we can love people, not despite but because of who they are, and how some moments just make that love grow, even when we already know it's not reciprocal.”
Chiron in Leo by Louise Hurrell
“I decided to trash ‘Chiron in Leo’ because I felt it never really fitted in anywhere. All of the magazines I looked into didn’t feel like a good home for the poem which in turn made me suspect the poem just wasn’t good at all. It’s also inspired by a night I was wide awake and looking through Astro.com (not a great idea!) and it felt quite silly as a premise so that also made me reluctant to publish it.”
Mr. Nice Guy by Louise Hurrell
TW* strong language
“Admittedly, I did have fun writing out my frustrations about nice guys but ultimately I didn’t think it was literary enough to be published. There isn’t a hidden meaning, there’s no real imagery or any writing techniques. People aren’t going to have multiple interpretations if they ever come back to it. It didn’t seem like anything people would want in their magazines. So I tucked away, never to see the light of day.”
Untitled #3 by Alexis Mitchell
“This was trashed because I was just venting in my notes app. I had just gotten out of a relationship, and while initially, I didn’t understand why things ended, I eventually came to terms with its conclusion. A lot of what I write in my notes app is usually prose pieces where I just let out all the thoughts floating in my mind—a stream of consciousness—but I never edit nor plan on submitting them to be published. I like to call all the things existing in my notes ‘word vomit’.”
Untitled #1 by Alexis Mitchell
“This was trashed because it felt cliché. Love is a popular theme in writing, and even though I tend to write about it often, I feel like it comes off unoriginal each time I do. I sometimes question what more could be said about love when so many have written about it or have had similar experiences.”
Untitled #2 by Alexis Mitchell
“This was trashed because it was another one of my “in my notes word vomiting vent sessions.” I was angry at myself, and writing has always been my outlet for my emotions. The thoughts expressed here are scattered, fragmented, and run-on-sentence-ish. I would never take the content below seriously enough for publication unless I were to tweak and edit it into what feels more formal or ‘perfect’.”
Yellow by Brenna Jeanneret
“It was rejected several times and I didn’t really know what else to do with it. This is not my usual style but when our dog died on our road trip it just came out.”
The Death Machine by Jessica Rowshandel
“This has been submitted to a few fellowship and mentorship programs to which I was not accepted. It was rejected by a lit mag who said “It's an interesting story, and we enjoyed the vivid imagery, but it didn't quite come together for us.” And I agree, it doesn’t. After the rollercoaster does its thing, the story kind of peters out. That’s maybe because it started out as the first chapter of a novel, and after being edited into different versions, I lost sight of why I included certain parts of the chapter; there are remnants that don’t make as much sense anymore. Then I tried using it as a standalone short story. Either way, I feel that at the very least it needs more momentum toward the end. I’m not sure if it will, one day, end up in that novel, and if it does, it will likely be re-worked.”
iMissWe by T A Jones
“I consider all of these poems trash because they were written in the moment and never touched again.
This was written back in 2018 while I was in a long distance relationship that just felt long and tiring but I wanted to keep going. I couldn’t bare let them go but I couldn’t be happy because of the hurdles and this was a poem that came out of that. I never shared it with them.”
The Trick of Falling In Love by T A Jones
“I consider all of these poems trash because they were written in the moment and never touched again.
This was written a few months after being all depressed and stuff and finding that we find love again. That it’s a trick. I can’t explain it but it just has this angsty thing to it that I don’t love. Granted they all have a bit of angst to them.”
The Loneliest Hour by Michael Driver
“This piece is called ‘The Loneliest Hour’ and I trashed it because I felt it was too sad. It felt too self-pitying and I didn’t like that I sounded so…whiny for lack of a better word. I wrote it at a very low point in my life and I didn’t want to be reminded of that point. But I hope in sharing it, someone else can relate and know that they might not be the only one feeling that way.”
The Future Tree by Damhuri Muhammad
“I wrote this story with my heart. I'm really sure, the work authored by the heart will also be accepted by the heart. Even though I was rejected many times, I don't care. Someday, there will be readers who welcome it with sincerity.”
Carnival of Masks & Miracles by Jenna Rose
“This idea had haunted me for a while, and I never was quite sure how to translate the imagery on my brain into words. When I finally did, I was glad to have pushed through to create this piece. However, with every reread, I became more and more convinced that this wasn't worth showing anywhere, so I shelved it. There are elements that I genuinely enjoy while other aspects may end up making this whole story a mess. While I still don't know if this would be worth it to be seen broadly, others may relate to this jumble of emotion around and within this story. And honestly, even if imperfect, this couple deserves a home.”
The Way We See The World by Ikechukwu Henry
“The Way We See The World was rejected multiple times by magazine that publishes queer-themed fiction. Each rejection came with ‘We love the story but...’ . But what? It wasn't good enough? It doesn't have what you are looking for? Questions like this was what I asked myself and writing began to lose hope, regretting writing it in the first place.”
Save Point by Steven Lister
“This one was inspired by an idea of wanting to have a piece based in conversation. I feel I failed to explore the emotional challenges that the main character was going through, and with each edit I made, it just felt protracted. I still like the concept, but couldn't write it down on paper.”
I Love You One by SJ Korzelius
“This was something I just had to verbalize once the lightbulb went on over my head after I texted my son, but never knew where to find it a home.”
Ambiguous Tour With Sequins by Laverne Zabielski
“I have written this in so many forms until it was finally forgotten since it always felt unfinished, and I’m concerned I tried to cover too many events and form in the same poem. But I like it.”
A Sense of Lost by Laverne Zabielski
“I’m exploring the relationship between the voice in our head that follows us and protects us and who we are in everyday life. It’s clear to me but I never was sure it translated to the page. Hence, under the bed this poem remains.”