Turriptopsis Dohrnil by Carly Chandler
“I scrapped this piece because I forgot that it existed. I wrote this personal essay and it remains a fossil.”
Virtuoso by Carly Chandler
“I scrapped this piece because the more I tried to write it like a ‘pretty piece of prose’, I just wanted to write a piece of horror. It wasn’t doing what I needed it to.”
Pen Names by Carly Chandler
“I wanted to like this poem a lot; I even read it at public reads more than once. I ultimately trashed this poem because it was an experiment in form that I felt just didn’t work out.”
Pedestrian, Longitudinal John & The Manor of Hollow Morrow by Garrett Souliere
“All of these poems come from a manuscript I am compiling in a similar spirit to trash to treasure’s mission – I am revising and reclaiming years of my idle, impulsive free writes and polishing them into something that means more.”
Angel by Oliver Kleyer
“I submitted this two or three times, until I received feedback for it. On the one hand, I could relate to the suggestions that were made. On the other hand, I just couldn’t find the right starting point for revision.”
Biographies & Let’s Go Out To A Movie Show by Ron Tobey
“Regarding ‘Let’s go out to a movie show’, I thought for a while about writing erotic poetry, and tried, but after widening my reading in erotic poetry, especially in the adult section of All Poetry, I realized that women write better erotic poetry and stories than I could and ever would. So, I just abandoned the piece. Re-reading, I think that was the right decision, as the poem is so teen boy POV that it never gets exciting.
‘Biographies’ has too much self-pity in it. I think that good poetry rises above self-pity. Again, it’s a youth’s poetry, not mature. Is there anything of worth in it? Maybe, if you were an activist once.”
An Email I Cannot Send You by Matti Blake
“I would say I can’t publish this because of how personal it is. I didn’t want to edit the personal pieces out because it’s integral to the story.”
Panic Attack & Is It Sin? by Treziel Mae Mayores
“Rather than trashed, these are some of the poems that were kept in a metaphorical chest with rusty locks, guarded with snakes. I am 21 now and these were written in the dark ages of my 15th year, like for example, the first one is literally a live word vomit during a panic episode. I am (glad to say) far better emotionally than before, and reading these poems brings a lot of ache and not-so-good memories that I would really like to forget, but I can’t, so they were just left to rot…”
Slug by M. L. Henderson
“This is a short piece I wrote and revised several times. I was always trying to add more. But it was about one intimate moment and I’ve realized that’s enough. So I pulled the oldest draft out of retirement and shortened it even more.”
A Smile that Melted an Anxious Heart by Jonathan Hunter
“I like this piece. It is intended to be a light, romantic story with a simple plot. I trashed it because publishers regularly overthink the piece and its characters.”
Poem of an Unfinished Story by Ennis Rook Bashe
“It is made of lines from a story I trashed due to feeling that it didn't have enough of a plot to be worth finishing. However, I wanted to take some of the lines from the piece and give them new life; hence, this poem.”
Flickers of Mnemosyne by Kaia Boyer
“While I did, wholeheartedly, enjoy writing it, this piece took one hell of a toll on me. It left me with that tight, sinking feeling in my chest, that I've got all the words out and the idea down but that it's just not good enough or up to my usual par. My writing peers told me differently, so I sent it out, but after a few rejections I was sure I was never going to find a good home for it nor be truly happy with it, and left it to sit in my little yellow-tagged folder in Finder, never used and rarely opened. But I love this piece and I love the concept I ended up with.”
Tongue by Adedayo Oluwaseyi Emmanuel
“At first, when the idea of this story came to me, I envisioned that it would turn into a mystery story. Unfortunately, I lose interest in the middle of writing it. I had no choice but to dump it.”
Haunted Skies by Adedayo Oluwaseyi Emmanuel
“I trashed my story, ‘Haunted Skies’, because I thought that since it was rejected by two horror publications, it wasn’t good enough.”
A Hymn of Grief, Prayer & Ode to the Bowl, Gulping Water from the Col by Olayioye Paul Bamidele
“I thrashed these set of poems due to internal reasons. When I first wrote these poems - most especially Hymn of Grief and the third poem - I felt I was resurrecting a grief memory. As climate change were fostering, most houses were flooded which form the basic part of the third poem. I remember how an infant was rescued, already death. It was saddening, so I cast them away. Until recently, I decided to revisit them and let the world know about these events.”
The Smiling Crowd & Preserved Hubris by Richard LeDue
“These two poems were rejected by another publication, and I was going to sit on them for a bit. I am a believer in that time can be a great editor, so my plan was to return to these pieces at some point in the future. However, I can be a bit forgetful and have actually unintentionally abandoned poems just because I never thought to go back and edit them.”
Tiny Love by Gaia
“I trashed this piece because it feels more like a personal letter to someone who never had the chance to hear it.”
Growing, Not Grown by Gaia
“I trashed this because it felt more like a reminder for myself to forgive my family for any mistakes they made while they were raising me, because if I was in their position I don’t know if my choices would be any different.”
Cancer Mercury by Dorothy Lune
“This poem (Cancer Mercury) is one that I really love but ultimately trashed because it reminds me of this blurry feeling of confusion I consistently have, maybe own; I'm unsure if I want to go to university or not, especially because of financial & personal related reasons. So, when I write academy I mean it literally. This feeling of the unknown or whatever it is, I don't like it at all, I like to enjoy things but not this, but ladybugs help.”
Adam’s Birthday by Dylan James
“I wrote this piece while hiding away at a party during my sophomore year of college. I trashed it because I was simply struggling to find my place in the world. I didn’t know who I was. Looking back, this piece is one of my favorites.”